The 2000 Rider female athlete of the year, Peel graduated with a Rider career record 2,777 assists in volleyball, including 684 as a senior. In softball, she earned All-East honors as a shortstop, leading the MAAC with a .397 batting average. She finished among the top nine in the MAAC in hits, doubles, triples, runs scored, home runs and stolen bases. She graduated eighth in Rider career hits with 173. Peel set a Rider record for career doubles with 45. She was a MAAC All-Academic team member in both volleyball and softball.