Rider University Wrestling All-Americans
| Name | Year | Place | Weight |
| John Carvalheira | 1997 | Seventh | 118 |
| John Carvalheira | 1998 | Eighth | 118 |
| Adam Derengowski | 1991 | Third | 118 |
| Lou DiSerafino | 1980 | Third | 190 |
| Francis Dunn | 1997 | Eighth | 142 |
| Don Fisch | 2007 | Fifth | 141 |
| Leo Giel | 1999 | Sixth | 174 |
| John Hangey | 1993 | Fourth | 190 |
| John Lucerne | 1985 | Fourth | 126 |
| Tim Morrison | 1983 | Fifth | 190 |
| Jason Nase | 1997 | Eighth | 134 |
| Shawn Scannell | 2000 | Eighth | 184 |
| Doug Umbehauer | 2009 | Third | 184 |
