Year

Result

Round

1998

#7 Manhattan 71, #2 Rider 58

Quarterfinals

1999

#7 Rider 73, #10 Manhattan 46

Opening Round

1999

#2 Siena 101, Rider 73

Quarterfinals

2000

#7 Rider 73, #10 Saint Peter's 58

Opening Round

2000

#2 Iona 64, Rider 59

Quarterfinals

2001

#4 Marist 70, #5 Rider 58

Quarterfinals

2002

#8 Canisius 85, #1 Rider 84 (ot)

Quarterfinals

2003

#8 Saint Peter's 77, #7 Rider 73 (ot)

Opening Round

2004

#5 Rider 75, #10 Loyola 67

Opening Round

2004

#4 Saint Peter's 79, Rider 69 (ot)

Quarterfinals

2005

#2 Rider 79, #7 Canisius 59

Quarterfinals

2005

Rider 76, #3 Fairfield 74

Semifinals

2005

#1 Niagara 81, Rider 59

Championship Game

2006

#5 Saint Peter's 80, #10 Rider 51

Opening Round

2007

#7 Rider 77, #10 Iona 62

Opening Round

2007

#2 Niagara 77, Rider 52

Quarterfinals

2008

#2 Rider 75, #10 Canisius 71

Quarterfinals

2008

Rider 76, #6 Marist 71

Semifinals

2008

#1 Siena 74, Rider 53

Championship Game

2009

#3 Rider 67, #6 Saint Peter's 58

Quarterfinals

2009

#2 Niagara 93, Rider 89 (2ot)

Semifinals

2010

#5 Rider 69, #4 Saint Peter's 57

Quarterfinals

2010

#1 Siena 72, #5 Rider 62

Semifinals

2011

#3 Rider 79, #6 Canisius 64

Quarterfinals

2011

#2 Iona 83, #3 Rider 59

Semifinals

2012

#4 Fairfield 65  #5 Rider 63

Quarterfinals